Civil Litigation

An Ontario Small Claims Court judgment is unpaid. When does a debtor examination help?

A debtor examination can help an unpaid creditor find out what a person or company owns, earns or expects to collect before deciding what to do next.

November 11, 20263 min read
Exterior of the A. Grenville and William Davis Courthouse in Brampton

Suppose a Mississauga bookkeeper wins a $6,000 judgment for unpaid invoices. The customer pays $500, then misses the next payment required by the order. The bookkeeper knows where to send an invoice, but has no idea where the customer works or whether they can pay the balance. That gap is a reason to consider a debtor examination.

Once a debtor defaults on a court order to pay money, Ontario’s Small Claims Court can require someone to answer questions under oath about the debtor’s finances. The answers can help the creditor (the person owed money) decide whether to pursue collection or propose instalments. The court can also make an order setting payment terms. See rule 20.10 of the Rules of the Small Claims Court.

Start with the name on the judgment

Compare the name on the signed order with the name you know from doing business. If the judgment names an individual, the creditor can ask about that person’s employment, property and debts. If it names an incorporated company, an officer or director can answer on the company’s behalf. In the bookkeeper’s example, that distinction determines whether the relevant question is “Who is your employer?” or “Which customers currently owe the company money?”

Work out the balance before requesting a hearing

Gather the order and make a dated list of payments. In this example the unpaid principal is $5,500, assuming the $500 payment was applied entirely to principal. Keep interest separate in your worksheet so you can explain the calculation. Form 20P, the sworn or affirmed enforcement request, asks for the award, payments received, applicable postjudgment interest rate and balance owing with interest.

Ask the clerk to issue a Notice of Examination (Form 20H) in the court division where the person you want to examine lives or carries on business. If the judgment came from another territorial division, the request also requires a Certificate of Judgment (Form 20A). Check the territorial division before paying a filing fee. Ontario’s guide to collecting after judgment.

Give notice and prepare questions you can use

The creditor must serve the issued notice at least 30 days before the examination, using personal service or an alternative permitted by rule 8.03. When examining an individual debtor, include a blank Financial Information Form (20I). Keep proof of service and file it with the notice in advance of the hearing. The individual debtor serves the completed financial form on the creditor, provides a copy to the judge at the hearing and brings supporting records. The completed financial form stays out of the court file. Ontario’s guide to serving Small Claims Court documents.

Use the hearing to fill specific gaps. If the debtor offers monthly payments, ask when the first payment could be made and which income will fund it. If a corporate debtor says an overdue customer account will cover the judgment, ask how much is owed, when it was due and whether the customer disputes it. Those answers give the bookkeeper a basis for assessing a payment proposal before spending more to collect.

Featured photograph of the A. Grenville and William Davis Courthouse in Brampton by Transportfan70. Original photograph · CC0 1.0.

This article is general information and not legal advice. It does not create a lawyer-client relationship. A lawyer-client relationship begins only after a conflict check is completed, KS Legal agrees to act, and a retainer agreement is signed. Past outcomes do not guarantee future results.