Can you pay an Ontario Small Claims Court claim in instalments?
A homeowner agrees with a roofer’s bill but needs six months to pay. Here is how to propose instalments and what happens if the roofer objects.
Suppose a Mississauga homeowner owes a roofer $3,600. The homeowner agrees the work was done and the bill is correct, but needs six months to pay. Once the roofer serves a Small Claims Court claim, the homeowner can use the court’s Defence form to admit the debt and propose instalments. Calling the roofer to explain the situation leaves the court’s response deadline running.
Put amounts and dates in your defence
You generally have 20 days after service of the claim to serve your Defence (Form 9A) on the other parties and file it with the court with proof of service. “Service” means delivering a document in a way the court rules allow. You can use the form to say how much you agree you owe, when you can make the first payment and how often you can pay after that. Ontario’s guide to replying to a claim explains how to complete and deliver the form.
In the roofing example, assume $3,600 is the entire amount claimed. An offer of $600 on the first of each month from January through June gives both people a schedule they can check. Before choosing that figure, the homeowner should look at what will be left in the account after rent or mortgage payments and other regular bills. If the homeowner already paid a deposit and the roofer forgot to credit it, that changes the answer on the form. The homeowner can identify the amount admitted, explain the disputed balance and attach the deposit receipt.
What if the roofer wants payment sooner?
The roofer has 20 days after service of the defence to challenge the proposed schedule by filing a Request to Clerk (Form 9B) and serving it on the homeowner. This asks for a terms of payment hearing, where the court can set payment dates and amounts. If the roofer lets that period pass without disputing the proposal, the homeowner must pay according to the schedule as though the court had ordered it. Rule 9.03 of the Rules of the Small Claims Court sets out both paths.
If a hearing is requested, an individual defendant receives a Financial Information Form (Form 20I) with the hearing notice. Complete it and serve it on the creditor before the hearing. The rule directs you to keep that form out of the court file. Attend the hearing even if you have already made the first payment. If you miss it, the clerk may sign judgment against you for the amount you admitted.
Keep a running balance
After two $600 payments, the homeowner’s record should show $2,400 outstanding. Keep a dated receipt or transfer confirmation for each payment. If an instalment under an undisputed proposal is missed, the creditor can serve a Notice of Default of Payment (Form 20L). Once 15 days have passed after service of that notice, the creditor can file a sworn Affidavit of Default of Payment (Form 20M) stating the default, what has been paid and what remains owing, to obtain judgment for the unpaid balance. If the court set the terms at a hearing, check the order itself and rule 9.03(7), which provides a different procedure for a missed payment.
Featured photograph by Canmenwalker of the historic Peel County Courthouse interior, resized and cropped for display. Original photograph · CC BY 4.0.
This article is general information and not legal advice. It does not create a lawyer-client relationship. A lawyer-client relationship begins only after a conflict check is completed, KS Legal agrees to act, and a retainer agreement is signed. Past outcomes do not guarantee future results.