Civil Litigation

Can a settlement offer increase your costs award in Ontario Small Claims Court?

A written offer can affect the costs awarded after trial. Check the service date, expiry terms and what the offer includes before sending it.

November 18, 20263 min read
Wooden benches facing the judge’s bench in the historic Peel County Courthouse

Yes. A plaintiff who makes an offer that the defendant rejects may qualify for a higher costs award if the eventual judgment is at least as favourable as the offer. Costs are the amount the court orders one party to contribute toward another party’s litigation expenses. The award remains the judge’s decision.

Under Rule 14.07, the court may award up to twice the plaintiff’s costs, excluding disbursements such as filing fees. The offer must have been made at least seven days before trial and must not have been withdrawn or expired before trial. Rule 14.02 also requires service on the other party at least seven days before trial begins. Rules of the Small Claims Court, Rule 14.07.

Put the terms in writing

You can use Form 14A or write a letter setting out the offer. Specify the amount, when payment is due and whether the amount includes interest and costs. Review any expiry date carefully before sending it. Ontario’s guide explains that acceptance must also be in writing and served on the person making the offer. An accepted offer binds both parties. Ontario’s guide to getting ready for Small Claims Court.

Keep the signed offer, the version actually sent and evidence of when and how it was served together. If several proposals have gone back and forth, a short dated list helps you identify which offer remained available.

An example of an expiry date that matters

Consider this hypothetical situation. A Mississauga business claims $9,000 on an unpaid invoice. It offers to settle for $7,500 but gives the defendant only 48 hours to accept. The offer expires weeks before trial. Even if the business later wins $9,000, that expired offer does not satisfy Rule 14.07’s conditions for the enhanced award. Before making an offer, ask your representative how its wording, service date and expiry fit your trial timetable.

Keep the offer out of your trial evidence

An unaccepted offer should not be filed at the court office. You must also keep the offer and related negotiations from the trial judge until liability and relief have been decided, apart from costs. Keep settlement correspondence in a separate folder when organising your trial documents. Ontario’s guidance on offers to settle.

When reviewing a proposal, compare the full terms with the evidence you can bring to trial and the time and expense still ahead. A clear payment date, an accurate account balance and a shared understanding of what resolves the claim can make the discussion more productive.

Illustrative photograph of the historic Peel County Courthouse interior by Canmenwalker, resized and cropped for display. Original photograph · CC BY 4.0.

This article is general information and not legal advice. It does not create a lawyer-client relationship. A lawyer-client relationship begins only after a conflict check is completed, KS Legal agrees to act, and a retainer agreement is signed. Past outcomes do not guarantee future results.