Civil Litigation

Can an exaggerated construction lien lead to damages in Ontario?

Check payments, credits and disputed extras before claiming a lien. Ontario’s Construction Act provides for damages where a lien is knowingly exaggerated.

November 19, 20263 min read
Pallets of red bricks wrapped in plastic beside concrete blocks

Yes. Ontario’s Construction Act can make a person liable for resulting damages if they preserve a lien, or give written notice of one, knowing or having reason to know that its amount has been wilfully exaggerated. The same provision addresses a person who knows or ought to know they have no lien. Before taking either step, give your lawyer a calculation that can be traced to the project records. Construction Act, section 35.

Reconcile the account before choosing a number

Start with the contract, approved changes, invoices, credit notes and payment history. Prepare a worksheet showing how you arrived at the unpaid balance. Put the date and document reference beside each entry so your lawyer can follow the calculation without reconstructing it from an inbox.

Flag disputed extras and explain the disagreement. For each extra, collect the instruction to do the work, the pricing discussion, any approval and the records showing what was supplied. Ask your lawyer which amounts can properly form part of the lien and what further evidence is needed.

A payment that changes the calculation

Consider a hypothetical Mississauga subcontractor whose ledger shows $28,000 outstanding. Before the lien paperwork is prepared, the subcontractor receives a $6,000 payment for that project. The updated worksheet should show both the receipt and the resulting $22,000 balance. Send the payment confirmation to the lawyer promptly, even if an earlier account statement has already been delivered.

If it is unclear which invoice a payment covers, include the payer’s remittance advice and explain the uncertainty. Keep the original records and document any correction. A reviewer should be able to see why a figure changed.

What if the amount is challenged?

Section 35 also allows the court, on a motion, to reduce the exaggerated portion in the circumstances described there if it finds good faith. That involves a court assessment of the facts. The section’s language about knowledge and wilful exaggeration matters when evaluating a disputed claim. Construction Act, section 35(2).

When asking for advice, send the calculation used for the claim, the documents supporting it and the other side’s specific objections. Identify any payment or credit received since the calculation was prepared. Ask your lawyer what should be corrected and what response is needed.

Give your lawyer the project dates at the same time as the financial records. Ask them to assess the applicable lien deadlines promptly while the account is being checked. An organised worksheet helps make that review practical when time is short.

Photo by Nenad Stojković (Shixart1985), resized and cropped for display. Bricks and concrete blocks at a construction site · CC BY 2.0.

This article is general information and not legal advice. It does not create a lawyer-client relationship. A lawyer-client relationship begins only after a conflict check is completed, KS Legal agrees to act, and a retainer agreement is signed. Past outcomes do not guarantee future results.